Relational conceptualizations of ethics for psychological research with children

symposium abstract

Research output: Contribution to conferenceConference abstract for conferenceResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Research ethics in psychology by and large build on a set of principles which emerged in response to severe ethical mistreatment of human research subjects in medical experiments. While these principles, like the Nuremberg Code of Ethics, undoubtedly marked a leap forward in ensuring research participants’ human rights, they have also met criticism. In 2012, for instance, the Association of Internet Researchers in an audit of its ethical recommendations observed that their recommendations reinforced the Nuremberg Code’s universally standardized, disciplinary/regulatory models of ethics and did not offer guidance in context-specific ethical sensibilities. In response, the associations’ revised ethical code suggests moving towards a more relational-consequentialist understanding of ethics, alike other social scientific fields.
These debates are highly relevant to psychology. The natural-scientific paradigm engrained in, for example, the Nuremberg Code, is ill-equipped for the study of psychological phenomena and does not address the innate problematic position of research participants as objects that can be experimented on and controlled. This mismatch becomes even more pertinent in research concerning children, for example regarding their assent. Overcoming a control-scientific ontology and epistemology and moving to more relational theories, highlights the need to inquire and re-conceptualize common ethical principles.
This symposium gathers four papers that present research conducted together with children instead of on children as mere objects to adult inquiry. Each paper draws on different philosophical inspirations and empirical insights in order to discuss the relevance of theorizing, negotiating and practicing ethics in more context-specific, relational ways.
Original languageEnglish
Publication date2017
Publication statusPublished - 2017
EventThe 17th Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology 2017: The Ethos of Theorizing - Rikkyo University, Tokyo, Japan
Duration: 21 Aug 201725 Aug 2017
Conference number: 17
https://www2.rikkyo.ac.jp/web/istp2017/index.html
https://www2.rikkyo.ac.jp/web/istp2017/topic4.html

Conference

ConferenceThe 17th Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology 2017
Number17
LocationRikkyo University
CountryJapan
CityTokyo
Period21/08/201725/08/2017
Internet address

Cite this

Chimirri, N. A., & Hilppö, J. (2017). Relational conceptualizations of ethics for psychological research with children: symposium abstract. Abstract from The 17th Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology 2017, Tokyo, Japan.
Chimirri, Niklas Alexander ; Hilppö, Jaakko. / Relational conceptualizations of ethics for psychological research with children : symposium abstract. Abstract from The 17th Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology 2017, Tokyo, Japan.
@conference{c19cae28b41447fab2278ffdec39935f,
title = "Relational conceptualizations of ethics for psychological research with children: symposium abstract",
abstract = "Research ethics in psychology by and large build on a set of principles which emerged in response to severe ethical mistreatment of human research subjects in medical experiments. While these principles, like the Nuremberg Code of Ethics, undoubtedly marked a leap forward in ensuring research participants’ human rights, they have also met criticism. In 2012, for instance, the Association of Internet Researchers in an audit of its ethical recommendations observed that their recommendations reinforced the Nuremberg Code’s universally standardized, disciplinary/regulatory models of ethics and did not offer guidance in context-specific ethical sensibilities. In response, the associations’ revised ethical code suggests moving towards a more relational-consequentialist understanding of ethics, alike other social scientific fields.These debates are highly relevant to psychology. The natural-scientific paradigm engrained in, for example, the Nuremberg Code, is ill-equipped for the study of psychological phenomena and does not address the innate problematic position of research participants as objects that can be experimented on and controlled. This mismatch becomes even more pertinent in research concerning children, for example regarding their assent. Overcoming a control-scientific ontology and epistemology and moving to more relational theories, highlights the need to inquire and re-conceptualize common ethical principles.This symposium gathers four papers that present research conducted together with children instead of on children as mere objects to adult inquiry. Each paper draws on different philosophical inspirations and empirical insights in order to discuss the relevance of theorizing, negotiating and practicing ethics in more context-specific, relational ways.",
author = "Chimirri, {Niklas Alexander} and Jaakko Hilpp{\"o}",
year = "2017",
language = "English",
note = "The 17th Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology 2017 : The Ethos of Theorizing, ISTP 2017 ; Conference date: 21-08-2017 Through 25-08-2017",
url = "https://www2.rikkyo.ac.jp/web/istp2017/index.html, https://www2.rikkyo.ac.jp/web/istp2017/topic4.html",

}

Chimirri, NA & Hilppö, J 2017, 'Relational conceptualizations of ethics for psychological research with children: symposium abstract' The 17th Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology 2017, Tokyo, Japan, 21/08/2017 - 25/08/2017, .

Relational conceptualizations of ethics for psychological research with children : symposium abstract. / Chimirri, Niklas Alexander; Hilppö, Jaakko.

2017. Abstract from The 17th Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology 2017, Tokyo, Japan.

Research output: Contribution to conferenceConference abstract for conferenceResearchpeer-review

TY - ABST

T1 - Relational conceptualizations of ethics for psychological research with children

T2 - symposium abstract

AU - Chimirri, Niklas Alexander

AU - Hilppö, Jaakko

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - Research ethics in psychology by and large build on a set of principles which emerged in response to severe ethical mistreatment of human research subjects in medical experiments. While these principles, like the Nuremberg Code of Ethics, undoubtedly marked a leap forward in ensuring research participants’ human rights, they have also met criticism. In 2012, for instance, the Association of Internet Researchers in an audit of its ethical recommendations observed that their recommendations reinforced the Nuremberg Code’s universally standardized, disciplinary/regulatory models of ethics and did not offer guidance in context-specific ethical sensibilities. In response, the associations’ revised ethical code suggests moving towards a more relational-consequentialist understanding of ethics, alike other social scientific fields.These debates are highly relevant to psychology. The natural-scientific paradigm engrained in, for example, the Nuremberg Code, is ill-equipped for the study of psychological phenomena and does not address the innate problematic position of research participants as objects that can be experimented on and controlled. This mismatch becomes even more pertinent in research concerning children, for example regarding their assent. Overcoming a control-scientific ontology and epistemology and moving to more relational theories, highlights the need to inquire and re-conceptualize common ethical principles.This symposium gathers four papers that present research conducted together with children instead of on children as mere objects to adult inquiry. Each paper draws on different philosophical inspirations and empirical insights in order to discuss the relevance of theorizing, negotiating and practicing ethics in more context-specific, relational ways.

AB - Research ethics in psychology by and large build on a set of principles which emerged in response to severe ethical mistreatment of human research subjects in medical experiments. While these principles, like the Nuremberg Code of Ethics, undoubtedly marked a leap forward in ensuring research participants’ human rights, they have also met criticism. In 2012, for instance, the Association of Internet Researchers in an audit of its ethical recommendations observed that their recommendations reinforced the Nuremberg Code’s universally standardized, disciplinary/regulatory models of ethics and did not offer guidance in context-specific ethical sensibilities. In response, the associations’ revised ethical code suggests moving towards a more relational-consequentialist understanding of ethics, alike other social scientific fields.These debates are highly relevant to psychology. The natural-scientific paradigm engrained in, for example, the Nuremberg Code, is ill-equipped for the study of psychological phenomena and does not address the innate problematic position of research participants as objects that can be experimented on and controlled. This mismatch becomes even more pertinent in research concerning children, for example regarding their assent. Overcoming a control-scientific ontology and epistemology and moving to more relational theories, highlights the need to inquire and re-conceptualize common ethical principles.This symposium gathers four papers that present research conducted together with children instead of on children as mere objects to adult inquiry. Each paper draws on different philosophical inspirations and empirical insights in order to discuss the relevance of theorizing, negotiating and practicing ethics in more context-specific, relational ways.

M3 - Conference abstract for conference

ER -

Chimirri NA, Hilppö J. Relational conceptualizations of ethics for psychological research with children: symposium abstract. 2017. Abstract from The 17th Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology 2017, Tokyo, Japan.