Projecting the Future for Design Science Research: An Action-Case Based Analysis

Richard Baskerville, Jan Pries-Heje

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingArticle in proceedingsResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    Design science research should be relevant, valuable, purposeful and prescriptive. Its value as a relevant source of prescriptions implies the practical usefulness of its results beyond a single expository instantiation. But propagation of such design science products as design principles and theories appears to be a key challenge. In this paper we commence with a DESRIST paper from 2012 that instantiated design principles in an artifact for a bank. That paper included plans and techniques for future use of its principles (propagation), including prescriptions for a five-phase adoption process. In this paper we discuss the propagation issues around generalizing design science research across multiple contexts and propose alternative propagation concepts of projectability and entrenchment. The existing concepts around generalizability have issues that make them less suitable for design science research: context (local/possible worlds) and theoretical statements based on functional explanations. A projection is any relevant instance that supports a theory. Projectability involves defining the relationship between a base case or evidence and a projection. Entrenchment occurs when design principles or theories have stimulated many actual projections. We demonstrate these concepts in a case study of propagation: a chemical manufacturer and service provider that adopted the design principles arising from that 2012 DESRIST banking-based design science research. We conclude that generalizability is too well-oriented to descriptive research and argue that a more appropriate framing for design science research is projectability and entrenchment. The paper includes recommendations to increase the projectability of design science research.
    Original languageEnglish
    Title of host publicationNew Horizons in Design Science : Broadening the Research Agenda
    EditorsBrian Donnellan, Markus Helfert, Jim Kenneally, Debra VanderMeer, Marcus Rothenberger, Robert Winter
    Volume9073
    PublisherSpringer
    Publication date2015
    Pages280-291
    ISBN (Print)978-3-319-18713-6
    ISBN (Electronic)978-3-319-18714-3
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2015
    Event10th International Conference - Clontarf Castle, Dublin, Ireland
    Duration: 20 May 201522 May 2015
    http://desrist2015.computing.dcu.ie/

    Conference

    Conference10th International Conference
    LocationClontarf Castle
    Country/TerritoryIreland
    CityDublin
    Period20/05/201522/05/2015
    Internet address
    SeriesLecture Notes in Computer Science
    Volume9073
    ISSN0302-9743

    Cite this