Planning as situated design

A preliminary report

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearch

Abstract

It is common to associate situated activity with concrete, craftlike or manual activity here and now and to reserve theoretical and abstract thinking for activities like theoretical experimentation and systematic planning. Much work has gone into demonstrating that these activities are concrete and situated, too. In this presentation it will be argued that the investigation of systematic planning as conflictual cooperation will help us see that situated activity is not only based on the present conditions, but also relates them to events spread out in time and space, thereby opening up for another understanding of theoretical thinking.
Some material from the empirical research project developed with Klaus Nielsen on the design and engineering of a house will be presented.
On this basis a conception of planning will be unfolded. It will be understood differently from the way it is understood in technological rational science. It will be seen as a dialectic between focussing on specific aspects and developing their context accordingly. Conflictual cooperation will be unfolded as the dialectics between participants, when they have to coordinate their perspectives on different aspects of the house, when they have to decide who among us does what with what to achieve this. It will be argued that this process contains moral and political aspects, as well as aspects of privilege, and that these aspects as well as the organising of planning takes shape from concrete conditions.
It will be argued that even though the house isn't there physically, it is present in praxis as professional perspectives, as the political praxis of reciprocally shaping each participant's contribution, and forming future obligations of who should do what. It will be argued that even though the planning goes systematically into any conceivable detail of the house to be built, still, unanticipated conditions appear during the whole process which must be taken into account. The planning is therefore not a realization of an idea, but a political development in the material and practical existence of the house.

Original languageEnglish
Publication date2009
Number of pages7
Publication statusPublished - 2009
EventThe Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology - Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing, China
Duration: 16 May 200919 May 2009

Conference

ConferenceThe Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology
LocationNanjing Normal University
CountryChina
CityNanjing
Period16/05/200919/05/2009

Keywords

  • building business
  • dialectics
  • coordination
  • conflictual cooperation
  • situated design

Cite this

Axel, E. (2009). Planning as situated design: A preliminary report. Paper presented at The Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology, Nanjing, China.
Axel, Erik. / Planning as situated design : A preliminary report. Paper presented at The Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology, Nanjing, China.7 p.
@conference{8e4c31a0c85f11de8998000ea68e967b,
title = "Planning as situated design: A preliminary report",
abstract = "It is common to associate situated activity with concrete, craftlike or manual activity here and now and to reserve theoretical and abstract thinking for activities like theoretical experimentation and systematic planning. Much work has gone into demonstrating that these activities are concrete and situated, too. In this presentation it will be argued that the investigation of systematic planning as conflictual cooperation will help us see that situated activity is not only based on the present conditions, but also relates them to events spread out in time and space, thereby opening up for another understanding of theoretical thinking.Some material from the empirical research project developed with Klaus Nielsen on the design and engineering of a house will be presented.On this basis a conception of planning will be unfolded. It will be understood differently from the way it is understood in technological rational science. It will be seen as a dialectic between focussing on specific aspects and developing their context accordingly. Conflictual cooperation will be unfolded as the dialectics between participants, when they have to coordinate their perspectives on different aspects of the house, when they have to decide who among us does what with what to achieve this. It will be argued that this process contains moral and political aspects, as well as aspects of privilege, and that these aspects as well as the organising of planning takes shape from concrete conditions.It will be argued that even though the house isn't there physically, it is present in praxis as professional perspectives, as the political praxis of reciprocally shaping each participant's contribution, and forming future obligations of who should do what. It will be argued that even though the planning goes systematically into any conceivable detail of the house to be built, still, unanticipated conditions appear during the whole process which must be taken into account. The planning is therefore not a realization of an idea, but a political development in the material and practical existence of the house.",
keywords = "building business, dialectics, coordination, conflictual cooperation, situated design",
author = "Erik Axel",
year = "2009",
language = "English",
note = "null ; Conference date: 16-05-2009 Through 19-05-2009",

}

Axel, E 2009, 'Planning as situated design: A preliminary report' Paper presented at, Nanjing, China, 16/05/2009 - 19/05/2009, .

Planning as situated design : A preliminary report. / Axel, Erik.

2009. Paper presented at The Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology, Nanjing, China.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearch

TY - CONF

T1 - Planning as situated design

T2 - A preliminary report

AU - Axel, Erik

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - It is common to associate situated activity with concrete, craftlike or manual activity here and now and to reserve theoretical and abstract thinking for activities like theoretical experimentation and systematic planning. Much work has gone into demonstrating that these activities are concrete and situated, too. In this presentation it will be argued that the investigation of systematic planning as conflictual cooperation will help us see that situated activity is not only based on the present conditions, but also relates them to events spread out in time and space, thereby opening up for another understanding of theoretical thinking.Some material from the empirical research project developed with Klaus Nielsen on the design and engineering of a house will be presented.On this basis a conception of planning will be unfolded. It will be understood differently from the way it is understood in technological rational science. It will be seen as a dialectic between focussing on specific aspects and developing their context accordingly. Conflictual cooperation will be unfolded as the dialectics between participants, when they have to coordinate their perspectives on different aspects of the house, when they have to decide who among us does what with what to achieve this. It will be argued that this process contains moral and political aspects, as well as aspects of privilege, and that these aspects as well as the organising of planning takes shape from concrete conditions.It will be argued that even though the house isn't there physically, it is present in praxis as professional perspectives, as the political praxis of reciprocally shaping each participant's contribution, and forming future obligations of who should do what. It will be argued that even though the planning goes systematically into any conceivable detail of the house to be built, still, unanticipated conditions appear during the whole process which must be taken into account. The planning is therefore not a realization of an idea, but a political development in the material and practical existence of the house.

AB - It is common to associate situated activity with concrete, craftlike or manual activity here and now and to reserve theoretical and abstract thinking for activities like theoretical experimentation and systematic planning. Much work has gone into demonstrating that these activities are concrete and situated, too. In this presentation it will be argued that the investigation of systematic planning as conflictual cooperation will help us see that situated activity is not only based on the present conditions, but also relates them to events spread out in time and space, thereby opening up for another understanding of theoretical thinking.Some material from the empirical research project developed with Klaus Nielsen on the design and engineering of a house will be presented.On this basis a conception of planning will be unfolded. It will be understood differently from the way it is understood in technological rational science. It will be seen as a dialectic between focussing on specific aspects and developing their context accordingly. Conflictual cooperation will be unfolded as the dialectics between participants, when they have to coordinate their perspectives on different aspects of the house, when they have to decide who among us does what with what to achieve this. It will be argued that this process contains moral and political aspects, as well as aspects of privilege, and that these aspects as well as the organising of planning takes shape from concrete conditions.It will be argued that even though the house isn't there physically, it is present in praxis as professional perspectives, as the political praxis of reciprocally shaping each participant's contribution, and forming future obligations of who should do what. It will be argued that even though the planning goes systematically into any conceivable detail of the house to be built, still, unanticipated conditions appear during the whole process which must be taken into account. The planning is therefore not a realization of an idea, but a political development in the material and practical existence of the house.

KW - building business

KW - dialectics

KW - coordination

KW - conflictual cooperation

KW - situated design

M3 - Paper

ER -

Axel E. Planning as situated design: A preliminary report. 2009. Paper presented at The Biennial Conference of the International Society for Theoretical Psychology, Nanjing, China.