Exemplary Design Practice: A discussion of the Applicability in Design Studies of the Principle of Exemplary Learning

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

Abstract

The didactic principle of exemplary learning may be defined briefly as 'learning by example'. In design education, working with a practical example is particularly appropriate, because design by definition is about creating a solution to a practical problem. Indeed, some design theorists claim that design knowledge and knowing is inseparable from practice, as in Donald Schön's suggestion that design education could be organized as a 'practicum' and based theoretically on an 'epistemology of practice'. However, the combination of exemplary learning and design studies does raise several questions, including: If design
knowing is bound to a given practical design context, how is it possible to generalize such knowing, as presumably required by an exemplary learning approach? To explore these questions, an account is given of the theories of exemplary learning proposed by Martin Wagenschein and Oskar Negt and the theories of design proposed by Herbert Simon and Schön. Simon's proposal of a generic science of design aligns well with Wagenschein's view of exemplary learning as a universal didactic approach. Therefore, in a sense, Simon's view is the most consistent with an exemplary learning approach. Conversely, Schön sees a large part of design knowledge as domain­specific, and aligns well with Oskar Negt's view of exemplary learning as a means to acquire a certain mode of thinking and acting, rather than insight into universal laws. Therefore, Schön's view is perhaps only partially consistent with an exemplary learning approach, and suggests caution about its implementation in design study programs.
The didactic principle of exemplary learning may be defined briefly as 'learning by example'. In design education, working with a practical example is particularly appropriate, because design by definition is about creating a solution to a practical problem. Indeed, some design theorists claim that design knowledge and knowing is inseparable from practice, as in Donald Schön's suggestion that design education could be organized as a 'practicum' and based theoretically on an 'epistemology of practice'. However, the combination of exemplary learning and design studies does raise several questions, including: If design
knowing is bound to a given practical design context, how is it possible to generalize such knowing, as presumably required by an exemplary learning approach? To explore these questions, an account is given of the theories of exemplary learning proposed by Martin Wagenschein and Oskar Negt and the theories of design proposed by Herbert Simon and Schön. Simon's proposal of a generic science of design aligns well with Wagenschein's view of exemplary learning as a universal didactic approach. Therefore, in a sense, Simon's view is the most consistent with an exemplary learning approach. Conversely, Schön sees a large part of design knowledge as domain­specific, and aligns well with Oskar Negt's view of exemplary learning as a means to acquire a certain mode of thinking and acting, rather than insight into universal laws. Therefore, Schön's view is perhaps only partially consistent with an exemplary learning approach, and suggests caution about its implementation in design study programs.

Conference

ConferenceVisions, Challenges and Strategies for Problem based Learning International onference, 4 - 6 MAY 2010 - at Aalborg University
CountryDenmark
CityÅlborg
Period04/05/201006/05/2010

Cite this

Jørgensen, N. (2010). Exemplary Design Practice: A discussion of the Applicability in Design Studies of the Principle of Exemplary Learning. Paper presented at Visions, Challenges and Strategies for Problem based Learning International onference, 4 - 6 MAY 2010 - at Aalborg University, Ålborg, Denmark.
Jørgensen, Niels. / Exemplary Design Practice : A discussion of the Applicability in Design Studies of the Principle of Exemplary Learning. Paper presented at Visions, Challenges and Strategies for Problem based Learning International onference, 4 - 6 MAY 2010 - at Aalborg University, Ålborg, Denmark.11 p.
@conference{c046976a159c441189ee841a99c9d316,
title = "Exemplary Design Practice: A discussion of the Applicability in Design Studies of the Principle of Exemplary Learning",
abstract = "The didactic principle of exemplary learning may be defined briefly as 'learning by example'. In design education, working with a practical example is particularly appropriate, because design by definition is about creating a solution to a practical problem. Indeed, some design theorists claim that design knowledge and knowing is inseparable from practice, as in Donald Sch{\"o}n's suggestion that design education could be organized as a 'practicum' and based theoretically on an 'epistemology of practice'. However, the combination of exemplary learning and design studies does raise several questions, including: If design knowing is bound to a given practical design context, how is it possible to generalize such knowing, as presumably required by an exemplary learning approach? To explore these questions, an account is given of the theories of exemplary learning proposed by Martin Wagenschein and Oskar Negt and the theories of design proposed by Herbert Simon and Sch{\"o}n. Simon's proposal of a generic science of design aligns well with Wagenschein's view of exemplary learning as a universal didactic approach. Therefore, in a sense, Simon's view is the most consistent with an exemplary learning approach. Conversely, Sch{\"o}n sees a large part of design knowledge as domain­specific, and aligns well with Oskar Negt's view of exemplary learning as a means to acquire a certain mode of thinking and acting, rather than insight into universal laws. Therefore, Sch{\"o}n's view is perhaps only partially consistent with an exemplary learning approach, and suggests caution about its implementation in design study programs.",
author = "Niels J{\o}rgensen",
year = "2010",
month = "5",
day = "4",
language = "English",
note = "null ; Conference date: 04-05-2010 Through 06-05-2010",

}

Exemplary Design Practice : A discussion of the Applicability in Design Studies of the Principle of Exemplary Learning. / Jørgensen, Niels.

2010. Paper presented at Visions, Challenges and Strategies for Problem based Learning International onference, 4 - 6 MAY 2010 - at Aalborg University, Ålborg, Denmark.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

TY - CONF

T1 - Exemplary Design Practice

T2 - A discussion of the Applicability in Design Studies of the Principle of Exemplary Learning

AU - Jørgensen,Niels

PY - 2010/5/4

Y1 - 2010/5/4

N2 - The didactic principle of exemplary learning may be defined briefly as 'learning by example'. In design education, working with a practical example is particularly appropriate, because design by definition is about creating a solution to a practical problem. Indeed, some design theorists claim that design knowledge and knowing is inseparable from practice, as in Donald Schön's suggestion that design education could be organized as a 'practicum' and based theoretically on an 'epistemology of practice'. However, the combination of exemplary learning and design studies does raise several questions, including: If design knowing is bound to a given practical design context, how is it possible to generalize such knowing, as presumably required by an exemplary learning approach? To explore these questions, an account is given of the theories of exemplary learning proposed by Martin Wagenschein and Oskar Negt and the theories of design proposed by Herbert Simon and Schön. Simon's proposal of a generic science of design aligns well with Wagenschein's view of exemplary learning as a universal didactic approach. Therefore, in a sense, Simon's view is the most consistent with an exemplary learning approach. Conversely, Schön sees a large part of design knowledge as domain­specific, and aligns well with Oskar Negt's view of exemplary learning as a means to acquire a certain mode of thinking and acting, rather than insight into universal laws. Therefore, Schön's view is perhaps only partially consistent with an exemplary learning approach, and suggests caution about its implementation in design study programs.

AB - The didactic principle of exemplary learning may be defined briefly as 'learning by example'. In design education, working with a practical example is particularly appropriate, because design by definition is about creating a solution to a practical problem. Indeed, some design theorists claim that design knowledge and knowing is inseparable from practice, as in Donald Schön's suggestion that design education could be organized as a 'practicum' and based theoretically on an 'epistemology of practice'. However, the combination of exemplary learning and design studies does raise several questions, including: If design knowing is bound to a given practical design context, how is it possible to generalize such knowing, as presumably required by an exemplary learning approach? To explore these questions, an account is given of the theories of exemplary learning proposed by Martin Wagenschein and Oskar Negt and the theories of design proposed by Herbert Simon and Schön. Simon's proposal of a generic science of design aligns well with Wagenschein's view of exemplary learning as a universal didactic approach. Therefore, in a sense, Simon's view is the most consistent with an exemplary learning approach. Conversely, Schön sees a large part of design knowledge as domain­specific, and aligns well with Oskar Negt's view of exemplary learning as a means to acquire a certain mode of thinking and acting, rather than insight into universal laws. Therefore, Schön's view is perhaps only partially consistent with an exemplary learning approach, and suggests caution about its implementation in design study programs.

M3 - Paper

ER -

Jørgensen N. Exemplary Design Practice: A discussion of the Applicability in Design Studies of the Principle of Exemplary Learning. 2010. Paper presented at Visions, Challenges and Strategies for Problem based Learning International onference, 4 - 6 MAY 2010 - at Aalborg University, Ålborg, Denmark.