Towards a conceptual framework for identifying student difficulties with solving Real-World Problems in Physics

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

Resumé

This paper develops a conceptual framework for identifying the challenges and obstacles university students encounter when solving real-world problems involving Physics. The framework is based on viewing problem solving as a modelling process. In order to solve a real-world problem, the problem solver has to go through the steps and do the tasks of such a process. The paper presents a theoretical analysis of what it takes to solve three real-world problems, demonstrating how the framework presented captures the essential aspects of solving them. Moreover, it is argued that three steps critical for real-world problem solving – initial analysis of the problem situation, choice of relevant physical theory (the so-called paradigmatic choice) and mathematization – are not covered by existing models of problem solving in Physics. Finally, the existing research on student difficulties with problem solving in Physics is placed within the framework.
OriginalsprogDansk
TidsskriftLatin - American Journal of Physics Education
Vol/bind6
Udgave nummer1
Sider (fra-til)3-13
Antal sider11
ISSN1870-9095
StatusUdgivet - mar. 2012

Emneord

  • Problemøsning
  • Virkelige problemer
  • universitetsniveau

Citer dette

@article{52b75f73e431445e88d788c23e34e75c,
title = "Towards a conceptual framework for identifying student difficulties with solving Real-World Problems in Physics",
abstract = "This paper develops a conceptual framework for identifying the challenges and obstacles university students encounter when solving real-world problems involving Physics. The framework is based on viewing problem solving as a modelling process. In order to solve a real-world problem, the problem solver has to go through the steps and do the tasks of such a process. The paper presents a theoretical analysis of what it takes to solve three real-world problems, demonstrating how the framework presented captures the essential aspects of solving them. Moreover, it is argued that three steps critical for real-world problem solving – initial analysis of the problem situation, choice of relevant physical theory (the so-called paradigmatic choice) and mathematization – are not covered by existing models of problem solving in Physics. Finally, the existing research on student difficulties with problem solving in Physics is placed within the framework.",
keywords = "Problem{\o}sning, Virkelige problemer, universitetsniveau",
author = "Martin Niss",
year = "2012",
month = "3",
language = "Dansk",
volume = "6",
pages = "3--13",
journal = "Latin - American Journal of Physics Education",
issn = "1870-9095",
publisher = "Instituto Polit{\'e}cnico Nacional, Latin American Physics Education Network",
number = "1",

}

Towards a conceptual framework for identifying student difficulties with solving Real-World Problems in Physics. / Niss, Martin.

I: Latin - American Journal of Physics Education, Bind 6, Nr. 1, 03.2012, s. 3-13.

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Towards a conceptual framework for identifying student difficulties with solving Real-World Problems in Physics

AU - Niss, Martin

PY - 2012/3

Y1 - 2012/3

N2 - This paper develops a conceptual framework for identifying the challenges and obstacles university students encounter when solving real-world problems involving Physics. The framework is based on viewing problem solving as a modelling process. In order to solve a real-world problem, the problem solver has to go through the steps and do the tasks of such a process. The paper presents a theoretical analysis of what it takes to solve three real-world problems, demonstrating how the framework presented captures the essential aspects of solving them. Moreover, it is argued that three steps critical for real-world problem solving – initial analysis of the problem situation, choice of relevant physical theory (the so-called paradigmatic choice) and mathematization – are not covered by existing models of problem solving in Physics. Finally, the existing research on student difficulties with problem solving in Physics is placed within the framework.

AB - This paper develops a conceptual framework for identifying the challenges and obstacles university students encounter when solving real-world problems involving Physics. The framework is based on viewing problem solving as a modelling process. In order to solve a real-world problem, the problem solver has to go through the steps and do the tasks of such a process. The paper presents a theoretical analysis of what it takes to solve three real-world problems, demonstrating how the framework presented captures the essential aspects of solving them. Moreover, it is argued that three steps critical for real-world problem solving – initial analysis of the problem situation, choice of relevant physical theory (the so-called paradigmatic choice) and mathematization – are not covered by existing models of problem solving in Physics. Finally, the existing research on student difficulties with problem solving in Physics is placed within the framework.

KW - Problemøsning

KW - Virkelige problemer

KW - universitetsniveau

M3 - Tidsskriftartikel

VL - 6

SP - 3

EP - 13

JO - Latin - American Journal of Physics Education

JF - Latin - American Journal of Physics Education

SN - 1870-9095

IS - 1

ER -