The Ethics of Child-soldiering in the Congo

Kasper Hoffmann

    Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

    Resumé

    In cutting-edge conflict theory, ‘young men’ are framed as a potential source of violence and insecurity in underdeveloped countries, especially in the so-called ‘failed states’. Supposedly, ‘young men’ bereft of socio-economic opportunities constitute a dangerous sub-population which can easily be recruited by ‘Spoilers’, or warlords when the pursuit of personal gain through the use of violence is rational; that is, in situations where the state has failed and therefore has no monopoly over the means of violence. Drawing on fieldwork among the Maï-Maï of South Kivu, I challenge the notion that the young fighters of the Maï-Maï were easily lured into the militias because they lacked other exit strategies. Recruitment actually followed a much more complex pattern. The young Maï-Maï fighters were either forcefully recruited or joined voluntarily for one or more of the following reasons: in order to exact vengeance on the ‘enemy’, for personal protection; to fight for national liberation; to protect a given community; for the right to enjoy the spoils of modernity; and to recast a disempowered and humiliated self into a vigorous and virile subject. In this article, therefore, I argue that recruitment into a non-state armed group was a question of ethics instead of the machinations of a universal instinct secretly at work.
    OriginalsprogEngelsk
    TidsskriftYoung - Nordic Journal of Youth Research
    Vol/bind18
    Udgave nummer3
    Sider (fra-til)339-358
    Antal sider20
    ISSN1103-3088
    DOI
    StatusUdgivet - 31 aug. 2010

    Emneord

      Citer dette

      Hoffmann, Kasper. / The Ethics of Child-soldiering in the Congo. I: Young - Nordic Journal of Youth Research. 2010 ; Bind 18, Nr. 3. s. 339-358.
      @article{0b155dff633043318e53e0c48001ffbb,
      title = "The Ethics of Child-soldiering in the Congo",
      abstract = "In cutting-edge conflict theory, ‘young men’ are framed as a potential source of violence and insecurity in underdeveloped countries, especially in the so-called ‘failed states’. Supposedly, ‘young men’ bereft of socio-economic opportunities constitute a dangerous sub-population which can easily be recruited by ‘Spoilers’, or warlords when the pursuit of personal gain through the use of violence is rational; that is, in situations where the state has failed and therefore has no monopoly over the means of violence. Drawing on fieldwork among the Ma{\"i}-Ma{\"i} of South Kivu, I challenge the notion that the young fighters of the Ma{\"i}-Ma{\"i} were easily lured into the militias because they lacked other exit strategies. Recruitment actually followed a much more complex pattern. The young Ma{\"i}-Ma{\"i} fighters were either forcefully recruited or joined voluntarily for one or more of the following reasons: in order to exact vengeance on the ‘enemy’, for personal protection; to fight for national liberation; to protect a given community; for the right to enjoy the spoils of modernity; and to recast a disempowered and humiliated self into a vigorous and virile subject. In this article, therefore, I argue that recruitment into a non-state armed group was a question of ethics instead of the machinations of a universal instinct secretly at work.",
      keywords = "Child soldiers, Ma{\"i}-Ma{\"i}, ethics, conflict, youth, security, rationality and morality",
      author = "Kasper Hoffmann",
      year = "2010",
      month = "8",
      day = "31",
      doi = "10.1177/110330881001800306",
      language = "English",
      volume = "18",
      pages = "339--358",
      journal = "Young",
      issn = "1103-3088",
      publisher = "Sage Publications India Pvt. Ltd.",
      number = "3",

      }

      The Ethics of Child-soldiering in the Congo. / Hoffmann, Kasper.

      I: Young - Nordic Journal of Youth Research, Bind 18, Nr. 3, 31.08.2010, s. 339-358.

      Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

      TY - JOUR

      T1 - The Ethics of Child-soldiering in the Congo

      AU - Hoffmann, Kasper

      PY - 2010/8/31

      Y1 - 2010/8/31

      N2 - In cutting-edge conflict theory, ‘young men’ are framed as a potential source of violence and insecurity in underdeveloped countries, especially in the so-called ‘failed states’. Supposedly, ‘young men’ bereft of socio-economic opportunities constitute a dangerous sub-population which can easily be recruited by ‘Spoilers’, or warlords when the pursuit of personal gain through the use of violence is rational; that is, in situations where the state has failed and therefore has no monopoly over the means of violence. Drawing on fieldwork among the Maï-Maï of South Kivu, I challenge the notion that the young fighters of the Maï-Maï were easily lured into the militias because they lacked other exit strategies. Recruitment actually followed a much more complex pattern. The young Maï-Maï fighters were either forcefully recruited or joined voluntarily for one or more of the following reasons: in order to exact vengeance on the ‘enemy’, for personal protection; to fight for national liberation; to protect a given community; for the right to enjoy the spoils of modernity; and to recast a disempowered and humiliated self into a vigorous and virile subject. In this article, therefore, I argue that recruitment into a non-state armed group was a question of ethics instead of the machinations of a universal instinct secretly at work.

      AB - In cutting-edge conflict theory, ‘young men’ are framed as a potential source of violence and insecurity in underdeveloped countries, especially in the so-called ‘failed states’. Supposedly, ‘young men’ bereft of socio-economic opportunities constitute a dangerous sub-population which can easily be recruited by ‘Spoilers’, or warlords when the pursuit of personal gain through the use of violence is rational; that is, in situations where the state has failed and therefore has no monopoly over the means of violence. Drawing on fieldwork among the Maï-Maï of South Kivu, I challenge the notion that the young fighters of the Maï-Maï were easily lured into the militias because they lacked other exit strategies. Recruitment actually followed a much more complex pattern. The young Maï-Maï fighters were either forcefully recruited or joined voluntarily for one or more of the following reasons: in order to exact vengeance on the ‘enemy’, for personal protection; to fight for national liberation; to protect a given community; for the right to enjoy the spoils of modernity; and to recast a disempowered and humiliated self into a vigorous and virile subject. In this article, therefore, I argue that recruitment into a non-state armed group was a question of ethics instead of the machinations of a universal instinct secretly at work.

      KW - Child soldiers

      KW - Maï-Maï

      KW - ethics

      KW - conflict

      KW - youth

      KW - security

      KW - rationality and morality

      U2 - 10.1177/110330881001800306

      DO - 10.1177/110330881001800306

      M3 - Journal article

      VL - 18

      SP - 339

      EP - 358

      JO - Young

      JF - Young

      SN - 1103-3088

      IS - 3

      ER -