The Development in Leading e-Government Articles 2001-2010

Definitions, Perspectives, Scope, Research Philosophies, Methods and Recommendations: An Update of Heeks and Bailur

Christian Østergaard Madsen, Jesper Bull Berger, MIck Phythian

    Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftKonferenceartikelForskningpeer review

    Resumé

    This paper presents a study of development in leading e-government papers from 2001-2010. Inspired by a study by Heeks and Bailur, the analysis uses a different sampling method, adds new themes, and focuses on changes over time. Through an iterative process known as template analysis the five most cited papers from each year are analyzed according to themes such as perspectives on the impact and impact causes of e-government, methods used, underlying research philosophies and recommendations. Findings indicate that the papers are still somewhat optimistic regarding the impact of e-government, but no longer as technologically deterministic. Discussions of research philosophies start to appear, as do social constructionist studies, although most papers are still positivistic. There is an increase in the use of primary data, and some movement in focus from infrastructure and services towards citizens. There is little development in the discussions of generalization of results and recom-mendations offered.
    OriginalsprogEngelsk
    BogserieLecture Notes in Computer Science
    Vol/bind8653
    Sider (fra-til)17-34
    Antal sider19
    ISSN0302-9743
    DOI
    StatusUdgivet - 2014

    Emneord

    • E-government
    • template analysis
    • literature review

    Citer dette

    @inproceedings{b71d42c64e454d6cab1f146a0fa89d3d,
    title = "The Development in Leading e-Government Articles 2001-2010: Definitions, Perspectives, Scope, Research Philosophies, Methods and Recommendations: An Update of Heeks and Bailur",
    abstract = "This paper presents a study of the development in leading egovernment papers from 2001-2010. Inspired by a study by Heeks and Bailur, the analysis uses a different sampling method, adds new themes, and focuses on changes over time. Through an iterative process known as template analysis the five most cited papers from each year are analyzed according to themes such as perspectives on the impact and impact causes of e-government, methods used, underlying research philosophies and recommendations. Findings indicate that the papers are still somewhat optimistic regarding the impact of e-government, but no longer as technologically deterministic. Discussions of research philosophies start to appear, as do social constructionist studies, although most papers are still positivistic. There is an increase in the use of primary data, and somemovement in focus from infrastructure and services towards citizens. There is little development in the discussions of generalization of results and recommendations offered.",
    keywords = "E-government, template analysis, literature review",
    author = "Madsen, {Christian {\O}stergaard} and Berger, {Jesper Bull} and MIck Phythian",
    year = "2014",
    doi = "10.1007/978-3-662-44426-9_2",
    language = "English",
    volume = "8653",
    pages = "17--34",
    journal = "Lecture Notes in Computer Science",
    issn = "0302-9743",
    publisher = "Physica-Verlag",

    }

    The Development in Leading e-Government Articles 2001-2010 : Definitions, Perspectives, Scope, Research Philosophies, Methods and Recommendations: An Update of Heeks and Bailur. / Madsen, Christian Østergaard; Berger, Jesper Bull; Phythian, MIck.

    I: Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Bind 8653, 2014, s. 17-34.

    Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftKonferenceartikelForskningpeer review

    TY - GEN

    T1 - The Development in Leading e-Government Articles 2001-2010

    T2 - Definitions, Perspectives, Scope, Research Philosophies, Methods and Recommendations: An Update of Heeks and Bailur

    AU - Madsen, Christian Østergaard

    AU - Berger, Jesper Bull

    AU - Phythian, MIck

    PY - 2014

    Y1 - 2014

    N2 - This paper presents a study of the development in leading egovernment papers from 2001-2010. Inspired by a study by Heeks and Bailur, the analysis uses a different sampling method, adds new themes, and focuses on changes over time. Through an iterative process known as template analysis the five most cited papers from each year are analyzed according to themes such as perspectives on the impact and impact causes of e-government, methods used, underlying research philosophies and recommendations. Findings indicate that the papers are still somewhat optimistic regarding the impact of e-government, but no longer as technologically deterministic. Discussions of research philosophies start to appear, as do social constructionist studies, although most papers are still positivistic. There is an increase in the use of primary data, and somemovement in focus from infrastructure and services towards citizens. There is little development in the discussions of generalization of results and recommendations offered.

    AB - This paper presents a study of the development in leading egovernment papers from 2001-2010. Inspired by a study by Heeks and Bailur, the analysis uses a different sampling method, adds new themes, and focuses on changes over time. Through an iterative process known as template analysis the five most cited papers from each year are analyzed according to themes such as perspectives on the impact and impact causes of e-government, methods used, underlying research philosophies and recommendations. Findings indicate that the papers are still somewhat optimistic regarding the impact of e-government, but no longer as technologically deterministic. Discussions of research philosophies start to appear, as do social constructionist studies, although most papers are still positivistic. There is an increase in the use of primary data, and somemovement in focus from infrastructure and services towards citizens. There is little development in the discussions of generalization of results and recommendations offered.

    KW - E-government

    KW - template analysis

    KW - literature review

    U2 - 10.1007/978-3-662-44426-9_2

    DO - 10.1007/978-3-662-44426-9_2

    M3 - Conference article

    VL - 8653

    SP - 17

    EP - 34

    JO - Lecture Notes in Computer Science

    JF - Lecture Notes in Computer Science

    SN - 0302-9743

    ER -