Practitioners – School ‘Mathematicians’

The Divisions of Pre-Modern Mathematics and Its Actors

Publikation: Bidrag til bog/antologi/rapportBidrag til bog/antologiForskningpeer review

Resumé

The paper starts by looking at how ‘practical’ and ‘theoretical’ mathematics and their relation
have been understood from the Greeks to Christian Wolff and by historians of mathematics
from Montucla to recent days. Drawing on earlier work of mine, and on the giants
on whose shoulders I (try to) stand, I then suggest a categorization of the mathematical knowledge types a historian has to deal with: the ‘sub-scientific’ type, carried by practitioners taught in an apprenticeship network; the ‘scholasticized’ type, taught supposedly for practice but in a ‘scribal’ school by masters whose own genuine practice is that of teaching; and the ‘scientific’ or theory-oriented type. In the end, the utility of this categorization is tried out on two specific cases.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
TitelStudies on the Ancient Exact Sciences in Honour of Lis Brack-Bernsen
RedaktørerJohn M. Steele, Mathieu Ossendrijver
Udgivelses stedBerlin
ForlagEdition Topoi
Publikationsdato2017
Sider207-224
ISBN (Trykt)978-3-9816384-5-5
DOI
StatusUdgivet - 2017
NavnTopoi - Berlin Studies of the Ancient World
Vol/bind44
ISSN2191-5806

Citer dette

Høyrup, J. (2017). Practitioners – School ‘Mathematicians’: The Divisions of Pre-Modern Mathematics and Its Actors. I J. M. Steele, & M. Ossendrijver (red.), Studies on the Ancient Exact Sciences in Honour of Lis Brack-Bernsen (s. 207-224). Berlin: Edition Topoi. Topoi - Berlin Studies of the Ancient World, Bind. 44 https://doi.org/10.17171/3-44
Høyrup, Jens. / Practitioners – School ‘Mathematicians’ : The Divisions of Pre-Modern Mathematics and Its Actors. Studies on the Ancient Exact Sciences in Honour of Lis Brack-Bernsen. red. / John M. Steele ; Mathieu Ossendrijver. Berlin : Edition Topoi, 2017. s. 207-224 (Topoi - Berlin Studies of the Ancient World, Bind 44).
@inbook{9bbf683586a14114befdb1cee63bcb7c,
title = "Practitioners – School ‘Mathematicians’: The Divisions of Pre-Modern Mathematics and Its Actors",
abstract = "The paper starts by looking at how ‘practical’ and ‘theoretical’ mathematics and their relationhave been understood from the Greeks to Christian Wolff and by historians of mathematicsfrom Montucla to recent days. Drawing on earlier work of mine, and on the giantson whose shoulders I (try to) stand, I then suggest a categorization of the mathematical knowledge types a historian has to deal with: the ‘sub-scientific’ type, carried by practitioners taught in an apprenticeship network; the ‘scholasticized’ type, taught supposedly for practice but in a ‘scribal’ school by masters whose own genuine practice is that of teaching; and the ‘scientific’ or theory-oriented type. In the end, the utility of this categorization is tried out on two specific cases.",
author = "Jens H{\o}yrup",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.17171/3-44",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-3-9816384-5-5",
pages = "207--224",
editor = "Steele, {John M.} and Mathieu Ossendrijver",
booktitle = "Studies on the Ancient Exact Sciences in Honour of Lis Brack-Bernsen",
publisher = "Edition Topoi",

}

Høyrup, J 2017, Practitioners – School ‘Mathematicians’: The Divisions of Pre-Modern Mathematics and Its Actors. i JM Steele & M Ossendrijver (red), Studies on the Ancient Exact Sciences in Honour of Lis Brack-Bernsen. Edition Topoi, Berlin, Topoi - Berlin Studies of the Ancient World, bind 44, s. 207-224. https://doi.org/10.17171/3-44

Practitioners – School ‘Mathematicians’ : The Divisions of Pre-Modern Mathematics and Its Actors. / Høyrup, Jens.

Studies on the Ancient Exact Sciences in Honour of Lis Brack-Bernsen. red. / John M. Steele; Mathieu Ossendrijver. Berlin : Edition Topoi, 2017. s. 207-224 (Topoi - Berlin Studies of the Ancient World, Bind 44).

Publikation: Bidrag til bog/antologi/rapportBidrag til bog/antologiForskningpeer review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Practitioners – School ‘Mathematicians’

T2 - The Divisions of Pre-Modern Mathematics and Its Actors

AU - Høyrup, Jens

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - The paper starts by looking at how ‘practical’ and ‘theoretical’ mathematics and their relationhave been understood from the Greeks to Christian Wolff and by historians of mathematicsfrom Montucla to recent days. Drawing on earlier work of mine, and on the giantson whose shoulders I (try to) stand, I then suggest a categorization of the mathematical knowledge types a historian has to deal with: the ‘sub-scientific’ type, carried by practitioners taught in an apprenticeship network; the ‘scholasticized’ type, taught supposedly for practice but in a ‘scribal’ school by masters whose own genuine practice is that of teaching; and the ‘scientific’ or theory-oriented type. In the end, the utility of this categorization is tried out on two specific cases.

AB - The paper starts by looking at how ‘practical’ and ‘theoretical’ mathematics and their relationhave been understood from the Greeks to Christian Wolff and by historians of mathematicsfrom Montucla to recent days. Drawing on earlier work of mine, and on the giantson whose shoulders I (try to) stand, I then suggest a categorization of the mathematical knowledge types a historian has to deal with: the ‘sub-scientific’ type, carried by practitioners taught in an apprenticeship network; the ‘scholasticized’ type, taught supposedly for practice but in a ‘scribal’ school by masters whose own genuine practice is that of teaching; and the ‘scientific’ or theory-oriented type. In the end, the utility of this categorization is tried out on two specific cases.

U2 - 10.17171/3-44

DO - 10.17171/3-44

M3 - Book chapter

SN - 978-3-9816384-5-5

SP - 207

EP - 224

BT - Studies on the Ancient Exact Sciences in Honour of Lis Brack-Bernsen

A2 - Steele, John M.

A2 - Ossendrijver, Mathieu

PB - Edition Topoi

CY - Berlin

ER -

Høyrup J. Practitioners – School ‘Mathematicians’: The Divisions of Pre-Modern Mathematics and Its Actors. I Steele JM, Ossendrijver M, red., Studies on the Ancient Exact Sciences in Honour of Lis Brack-Bernsen. Berlin: Edition Topoi. 2017. s. 207-224. (Topoi - Berlin Studies of the Ancient World, Bind 44). https://doi.org/10.17171/3-44