Multiculturalism and contextualism

How is context relevant for political theory?

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

Resumé

Many political theorists of multiculturalism (e.g. Joseph Carens, Bhikhu Parekh, James Tully) describe their theories as ‘‘contextualist.’’ But it is unclear what ‘‘contextualism’’ means and what difference it makes for political theory. I use a specific prominent example of a multiculturalist discussion, namely Tariq Modood’s argument about ‘‘moderate secularism,’’ as a test case and distinguish between different senses of contextualism. I discuss whether the claim that political theory is contextual in each sense is novel and interesting, and whether contextualism is a distinct feature of political theory of multiculturalism. I argue that the forms of contextualism which concern the scope and methodology of political theory are sensible, but not novel or distinctive of multiculturalism. I then discuss the more controversial forms of contextualism, which I call political and theoretical contextualism. Finally, I apply the distinctions to Modood’s argument. I argue that it is not a form of theoretical contextualism and that theoretical contextualism would in fact undermine arguments for multiculturalist policies of accommodation.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
TidsskriftEuropean Journal of Political Theory
Vol/bind14
Udgave nummer3
Sider (fra-til)259-276
Antal sider18
ISSN1474-8851
DOI
StatusUdgivet - 29 jun. 2015

Emneord

  • Kontekstualisme
  • Multikulturalisme
  • politisk teori
  • metodologi
  • Sekularisme

Citer dette

@article{d942153851b94ad6a2096c959ee19502,
title = "Multiculturalism and contextualism: How is context relevant for political theory?",
abstract = "Many political theorists of multiculturalism (e.g. Joseph Carens, Bhikhu Parekh, James Tully) describe their theories as “contextualist.” But it is unclear what “contextualism” means and what difference it makes for political theory. I use a specific prominent example of a multiculturalist discussion, namely Tariq Modood’s argument about “moderate secularism,” as a test case and distinguish between different senses of contextualism. I discuss whether the claim that political theory is contextual in each sense is novel and interesting, and whether contextualism is a distinct feature of political theory of multiculturalism. I argue that the forms of contextualism which concern the scope and methodology of political theory are sensible, but not novel or distinctive of multiculturalism. I then discuss the more controversial forms of contextualism, which I call political and theoretical contextualism. Finally, I apply the distinctions to Modood’s argument. I argue that it is not a form of theoretical contextualism and that theoretical contextualism would in fact undermine arguments for multiculturalist policies of accommodation.",
keywords = "Kontekstualisme, Multikulturalisme, politisk teori, metodologi, Sekularisme, Contextualism, Multiculturalism, Political theory, methodology, secularism",
author = "Sune L{\ae}gaard",
year = "2015",
month = "6",
day = "29",
doi = "10.1177/1474885114562975",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
pages = "259--276",
journal = "European Journal of Political Theory",
issn = "1474-8851",
publisher = "SAGE Publications",
number = "3",

}

Multiculturalism and contextualism : How is context relevant for political theory? / Lægaard, Sune.

I: European Journal of Political Theory, Bind 14, Nr. 3, 29.06.2015, s. 259-276.

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Multiculturalism and contextualism

T2 - How is context relevant for political theory?

AU - Lægaard, Sune

PY - 2015/6/29

Y1 - 2015/6/29

N2 - Many political theorists of multiculturalism (e.g. Joseph Carens, Bhikhu Parekh, James Tully) describe their theories as “contextualist.” But it is unclear what “contextualism” means and what difference it makes for political theory. I use a specific prominent example of a multiculturalist discussion, namely Tariq Modood’s argument about “moderate secularism,” as a test case and distinguish between different senses of contextualism. I discuss whether the claim that political theory is contextual in each sense is novel and interesting, and whether contextualism is a distinct feature of political theory of multiculturalism. I argue that the forms of contextualism which concern the scope and methodology of political theory are sensible, but not novel or distinctive of multiculturalism. I then discuss the more controversial forms of contextualism, which I call political and theoretical contextualism. Finally, I apply the distinctions to Modood’s argument. I argue that it is not a form of theoretical contextualism and that theoretical contextualism would in fact undermine arguments for multiculturalist policies of accommodation.

AB - Many political theorists of multiculturalism (e.g. Joseph Carens, Bhikhu Parekh, James Tully) describe their theories as “contextualist.” But it is unclear what “contextualism” means and what difference it makes for political theory. I use a specific prominent example of a multiculturalist discussion, namely Tariq Modood’s argument about “moderate secularism,” as a test case and distinguish between different senses of contextualism. I discuss whether the claim that political theory is contextual in each sense is novel and interesting, and whether contextualism is a distinct feature of political theory of multiculturalism. I argue that the forms of contextualism which concern the scope and methodology of political theory are sensible, but not novel or distinctive of multiculturalism. I then discuss the more controversial forms of contextualism, which I call political and theoretical contextualism. Finally, I apply the distinctions to Modood’s argument. I argue that it is not a form of theoretical contextualism and that theoretical contextualism would in fact undermine arguments for multiculturalist policies of accommodation.

KW - Kontekstualisme

KW - Multikulturalisme

KW - politisk teori

KW - metodologi

KW - Sekularisme

KW - Contextualism

KW - Multiculturalism

KW - Political theory

KW - methodology

KW - secularism

U2 - 10.1177/1474885114562975

DO - 10.1177/1474885114562975

M3 - Journal article

VL - 14

SP - 259

EP - 276

JO - European Journal of Political Theory

JF - European Journal of Political Theory

SN - 1474-8851

IS - 3

ER -