GMO neighbourhoods - will co-existence be a geographically realistic possibility?

H. Witt Qvist, H. Lundsgaard, Jesper Brandt

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelpeer review

Abstract

In Denmark, there has been widespread opposition to the use of Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO’s) as a result of which rules have been developed relating to the co-existence of GM, conventionally and organically produced crops. This has been in the form of a spatially elaborated implementation of the precautionary principle adopted in the Maastricht treaty from 1992 by the EU (Andersen, 2000). We concretised these rules in relation to actual landscape practices among primary producers of sugar beet in Denmark, we simulated the co-existence of GM and conventional sugar beet in an area of intensive sugar beet production on Lolland, South Eastern Denmark. The theoretical basis for our work finds three major sources of inspiration namely Ulrich Beck’s theory of the `Risk Society´, Torsten Hägerstrand’s concept of `the progress landscape´ and its relation to the social practices of land users, and Brian Wynne’s studies of the discrepancy between theoretical and practical knowledge related to environmental risk. The farmers, who were involved in the study, were interviewed concerning their opinions on land use practices in cases of co-existence. Interviews were carried out both before and after the study took place. It is concluded that although the farmers are positive towards the possibility of introducing GM sugar beet, it is not realistic to expect the rules of co-existence to be observed, which makes the risk assessment behind the new rules unrealistical. Further studies of social practice in relation to trends and geographical variations in the distribution of structure, size and fragmentation of agricultural holdings are recommended in order to investigate possibilities for realistic co-existence.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
TidsskriftGeografiska Annaler. Series B. Human Geography
Vol/bind88B
Udgave nummer2
Sider (fra-til)199-213
Antal sider15
ISSN0435-3684
StatusUdgivet - 2006

Citer dette