Failures of the State Failure Debate

evidence from the Somali territories

Tobias Hagmann, Markus V. Hoehne

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

Resumé

Much of the current literature on state failure and collapse suffers from serious
conceptual flaws. It ignores the variegated types of empirical statehood that exist on the ground, it conflates the absence of a central government with anarchy, it creates an unhelpful distinction between ‘accomplished’ and ‘failed’ states, and it is guided by a teleological belief in the convergence of all nation-states. Particularly African states figure prominently in this debate and are frequently portrayed in almost pathological terms. Proposing a comparative analysis of politics in the Somali inhabited territories of the Horn of Africa, this article
challenges state failure discourses on both theoretical and empirical grounds. We draw attention to the multiple processes of state-building and forms of statehood that have emerged in Somalia, and the neighbouring Somalia region of Ethiopia, since 1991. The analysis of the different trajectories of these Somali political orders reveals that state formation in Africa contradicts central tenets of the state failure debate and that external state-building interventions should recognise and engage with sub-national political entities.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
TidsskriftJournal of International Development
Vol/bind21
Udgave nummer1
Sider (fra-til)42-57
ISSN0954-1748
DOI
StatusUdgivet - 2009
Udgivet eksterntJa

Citer dette

@article{7f6d138564e84bd29dbf595e2e5a77f3,
title = "Failures of the State Failure Debate: evidence from the Somali territories",
abstract = "Much of the current literature on state failure and collapse suffers from seriousconceptual flaws. It ignores the variegated types of empirical statehood that exist on the ground, it conflates the absence of a central government with anarchy, it creates an unhelpful distinction between ‘accomplished’ and ‘failed’ states, and it is guided by a teleological belief in the convergence of all nation-states. Particularly African states figure prominently in this debate and are frequently portrayed in almost pathological terms. Proposing a comparative analysis of politics in the Somali inhabited territories of the Horn of Africa, this articlechallenges state failure discourses on both theoretical and empirical grounds. We draw attention to the multiple processes of state-building and forms of statehood that have emerged in Somalia, and the neighbouring Somalia region of Ethiopia, since 1991. The analysis of the different trajectories of these Somali political orders reveals that state formation in Africa contradicts central tenets of the state failure debate and that external state-building interventions should recognise and engage with sub-national political entities.",
author = "Tobias Hagmann and Hoehne, {Markus V.}",
year = "2009",
doi = "10.1002/jid.1482",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "42--57",
journal = "Journal of International Development",
issn = "0954-1748",
publisher = "JohnWiley & Sons Ltd.",
number = "1",

}

Failures of the State Failure Debate : evidence from the Somali territories . / Hagmann, Tobias; Hoehne, Markus V.

I: Journal of International Development, Bind 21, Nr. 1, 2009, s. 42-57.

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Failures of the State Failure Debate

T2 - evidence from the Somali territories

AU - Hagmann, Tobias

AU - Hoehne, Markus V.

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - Much of the current literature on state failure and collapse suffers from seriousconceptual flaws. It ignores the variegated types of empirical statehood that exist on the ground, it conflates the absence of a central government with anarchy, it creates an unhelpful distinction between ‘accomplished’ and ‘failed’ states, and it is guided by a teleological belief in the convergence of all nation-states. Particularly African states figure prominently in this debate and are frequently portrayed in almost pathological terms. Proposing a comparative analysis of politics in the Somali inhabited territories of the Horn of Africa, this articlechallenges state failure discourses on both theoretical and empirical grounds. We draw attention to the multiple processes of state-building and forms of statehood that have emerged in Somalia, and the neighbouring Somalia region of Ethiopia, since 1991. The analysis of the different trajectories of these Somali political orders reveals that state formation in Africa contradicts central tenets of the state failure debate and that external state-building interventions should recognise and engage with sub-national political entities.

AB - Much of the current literature on state failure and collapse suffers from seriousconceptual flaws. It ignores the variegated types of empirical statehood that exist on the ground, it conflates the absence of a central government with anarchy, it creates an unhelpful distinction between ‘accomplished’ and ‘failed’ states, and it is guided by a teleological belief in the convergence of all nation-states. Particularly African states figure prominently in this debate and are frequently portrayed in almost pathological terms. Proposing a comparative analysis of politics in the Somali inhabited territories of the Horn of Africa, this articlechallenges state failure discourses on both theoretical and empirical grounds. We draw attention to the multiple processes of state-building and forms of statehood that have emerged in Somalia, and the neighbouring Somalia region of Ethiopia, since 1991. The analysis of the different trajectories of these Somali political orders reveals that state formation in Africa contradicts central tenets of the state failure debate and that external state-building interventions should recognise and engage with sub-national political entities.

U2 - 10.1002/jid.1482

DO - 10.1002/jid.1482

M3 - Journal article

VL - 21

SP - 42

EP - 57

JO - Journal of International Development

JF - Journal of International Development

SN - 0954-1748

IS - 1

ER -