Concepts and Contexts – Argumentative Forms of Framing

Publikation: Bidrag til bog/antologi/rapportBidrag til bog/antologiForskningpeer review

Resumé

The notion of framing has become central in the field of argumentation. The question is, however, what we gain from studying the process of argumentation through framing, since framing is itself a broad concept in need of specification. Different traditions understand the term differently, and it is necessary to determine what argumentative forms the concept of framing actually covers. In this paper we argue that framing refers to at least two different argumentative forms. One is an internal definition of the concepts in question; the other is an external shift in the context of the case. In making this argument we combine theories of framing with the classical rhetorical theory of the stases, more precisely status definitio and status translatio. Our focus is primarily theoretical, but we illustrate our points by means of examples taken from public debates on the value of real estate.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
TitelProceedings of the 7th Conference of the Society for the Study of Argumentation
RedaktørerFrans H. van Eemeren, B. Garssen, D. Godden
Antal sider11
Vol/bind2011
Udgivelses stedAmsterdam
ForlagRozenberg Publishers
Publikationsdato2011
Sider533-543
Kapitel48
ISBN (Trykt)978 90 3610 243 8
StatusUdgivet - 2011

Emneord

  • Framing, stasis, retorik

Citer dette

Gabrielsen, J., Just, S. N., & Bengtsson, M. (2011). Concepts and Contexts – Argumentative Forms of Framing. I F. H. van Eemeren, B. Garssen, & D. Godden (red.), Proceedings of the 7th Conference of the Society for the Study of Argumentation (Bind 2011, s. 533-543). Amsterdam: Rozenberg Publishers .
Gabrielsen, Jonas ; Just, Sine Nørholm ; Bengtsson, Mette. / Concepts and Contexts – Argumentative Forms of Framing. Proceedings of the 7th Conference of the Society for the Study of Argumentation . red. / Frans H. van Eemeren ; B. Garssen ; D. Godden. Bind 2011 Amsterdam : Rozenberg Publishers , 2011. s. 533-543
@inbook{b5cc0929568a435bb13779ddb5ca474a,
title = "Concepts and Contexts – Argumentative Forms of Framing",
abstract = "The notion of framing has become central in the field of argumentation. The question is, however, what we gain from studying the process of argumentation through framing, since framing is itself a broad concept in need of specification. Different traditions understand the term differently, and it is necessary to determine what argumentative forms the concept of framing actually covers. In this paper we argue that framing refers to at least two different argumentative forms. One is an internal definition of the concepts in question; the other is an external shift in the context of the case. In making this argument we combine theories of framing with the classical rhetorical theory of the stases, more precisely status definitio and status translatio. Our focus is primarily theoretical, but we illustrate our points by means of examples taken from public debates on the value of real estate.",
keywords = "Framing, stasis, retorik",
author = "Jonas Gabrielsen and Just, {Sine N{\o}rholm} and Mette Bengtsson",
year = "2011",
language = "English",
isbn = "978 90 3610 243 8",
volume = "2011",
pages = "533--543",
editor = "{H. van Eemeren}, {Frans } and B. Garssen and D. Godden",
booktitle = "Proceedings of the 7th Conference of the Society for the Study of Argumentation",
publisher = "Rozenberg Publishers",

}

Gabrielsen, J, Just, SN & Bengtsson, M 2011, Concepts and Contexts – Argumentative Forms of Framing. i F H. van Eemeren, B Garssen & D Godden (red), Proceedings of the 7th Conference of the Society for the Study of Argumentation . bind 2011, Rozenberg Publishers , Amsterdam, s. 533-543.

Concepts and Contexts – Argumentative Forms of Framing. / Gabrielsen, Jonas; Just, Sine Nørholm; Bengtsson, Mette.

Proceedings of the 7th Conference of the Society for the Study of Argumentation . red. / Frans H. van Eemeren; B. Garssen; D. Godden. Bind 2011 Amsterdam : Rozenberg Publishers , 2011. s. 533-543.

Publikation: Bidrag til bog/antologi/rapportBidrag til bog/antologiForskningpeer review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Concepts and Contexts – Argumentative Forms of Framing

AU - Gabrielsen, Jonas

AU - Just, Sine Nørholm

AU - Bengtsson, Mette

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - The notion of framing has become central in the field of argumentation. The question is, however, what we gain from studying the process of argumentation through framing, since framing is itself a broad concept in need of specification. Different traditions understand the term differently, and it is necessary to determine what argumentative forms the concept of framing actually covers. In this paper we argue that framing refers to at least two different argumentative forms. One is an internal definition of the concepts in question; the other is an external shift in the context of the case. In making this argument we combine theories of framing with the classical rhetorical theory of the stases, more precisely status definitio and status translatio. Our focus is primarily theoretical, but we illustrate our points by means of examples taken from public debates on the value of real estate.

AB - The notion of framing has become central in the field of argumentation. The question is, however, what we gain from studying the process of argumentation through framing, since framing is itself a broad concept in need of specification. Different traditions understand the term differently, and it is necessary to determine what argumentative forms the concept of framing actually covers. In this paper we argue that framing refers to at least two different argumentative forms. One is an internal definition of the concepts in question; the other is an external shift in the context of the case. In making this argument we combine theories of framing with the classical rhetorical theory of the stases, more precisely status definitio and status translatio. Our focus is primarily theoretical, but we illustrate our points by means of examples taken from public debates on the value of real estate.

KW - Framing, stasis, retorik

M3 - Book chapter

SN - 978 90 3610 243 8

VL - 2011

SP - 533

EP - 543

BT - Proceedings of the 7th Conference of the Society for the Study of Argumentation

A2 - H. van Eemeren, Frans

A2 - Garssen, B.

A2 - Godden, D.

PB - Rozenberg Publishers

CY - Amsterdam

ER -

Gabrielsen J, Just SN, Bengtsson M. Concepts and Contexts – Argumentative Forms of Framing. I H. van Eemeren F, Garssen B, Godden D, red., Proceedings of the 7th Conference of the Society for the Study of Argumentation . Bind 2011. Amsterdam: Rozenberg Publishers . 2011. s. 533-543