Attitudinal Analyses of Toleration and Respect and the Problem of Institutional Applicability

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

Resumé

Toleration and respect are types of relations between different agents. The standard analyses of toleration and respect are attitudinal; toleration and respect require subjects to have appropriate types of attitudes towards the objects of toleration or respect. The paper investigates whether states can sensibly be described as tolerant or respectful in ways theoretically relevantly similar to the standard analyses. This is a descriptive question about the applicability of concepts rather than a normative question about whether, when and why states should be tolerant or respectful. The problem of institutional application is that institutions in general and the state in particular arguably cannot have attitudes of the required kind. This problem is distinct from, and broader than, well-known problems about whether political toleration is normatively legitimate. To make sense of political toleration or respect, the paper proposes that the analysis of institutional toleration and respect should not be solely agent-centred (as in attitudinal analyses) or patient-centred (as in explanations of the good of toleration or respect in terms of the effects of being tolerated or respected). The analysis should also include features about the relation itself. We can describe institutions as tolerant or respectful in a sense relevantly similar to the standard analyses if we focus on the public features of the relation between institutions and citizens or groups, without ascribing attitudes in the problematic sense.
OriginalsprogEngelsk
TidsskriftEuropean Journal of Philosophy
Vol/bind23
Udgave nummer4
Sider (fra-til)1064–1081
Antal sider18
ISSN0966-8373
DOI
StatusUdgivet - dec. 2015

Emneord

  • toleration
  • respect
  • state
  • institution
  • attitudes

Citer dette

@article{774187fb850e4874a7db1d3b333e30d1,
title = "Attitudinal Analyses of Toleration and Respect and the Problem of Institutional Applicability",
abstract = "Toleration and respect are types of relations between different agents. The standard analyses of toleration and respect are attitudinal; toleration and respect require subjects to have appropriate types of attitudes towards the objects of toleration or respect. The paper investigates whether states can sensibly be described as tolerant or respectful in ways theoretically relevantly similar to the standard analyses. This is a descriptive question about the applicability of concepts rather than a normative question about whether, when and why states should be tolerant or respectful. The problem of institutional application is that institutions in general and the state in particular arguably cannot have attitudes of the required kind. This problem is distinct from, and broader than, well-known problems about whether political toleration is normatively legitimate. To make sense of political toleration or respect, the paper proposes that the analysis of institutional toleration and respect should not be solely agent-centred (as in attitudinal analyses) or patient-centred (as in explanations of the good of toleration or respect in terms of the effects of being tolerated or respected). The analysis should also include features about the relation itself. We can describe institutions as tolerant or respectful in a sense relevantly similar to the standard analyses if we focus on the public features of the relation between institutions and citizens or groups, without ascribing attitudes in the problematic sense.",
keywords = "toleration, respect, state, institution, attitudes",
author = "Sune L{\ae}gaard",
year = "2015",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1111/ejop.12027",
language = "English",
volume = "23",
pages = "1064–1081",
journal = "European Journal of Philosophy",
issn = "0966-8373",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell Publishing Ltd.",
number = "4",

}

Attitudinal Analyses of Toleration and Respect and the Problem of Institutional Applicability. / Lægaard, Sune.

I: European Journal of Philosophy, Bind 23, Nr. 4, 12.2015, s. 1064–1081.

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Attitudinal Analyses of Toleration and Respect and the Problem of Institutional Applicability

AU - Lægaard, Sune

PY - 2015/12

Y1 - 2015/12

N2 - Toleration and respect are types of relations between different agents. The standard analyses of toleration and respect are attitudinal; toleration and respect require subjects to have appropriate types of attitudes towards the objects of toleration or respect. The paper investigates whether states can sensibly be described as tolerant or respectful in ways theoretically relevantly similar to the standard analyses. This is a descriptive question about the applicability of concepts rather than a normative question about whether, when and why states should be tolerant or respectful. The problem of institutional application is that institutions in general and the state in particular arguably cannot have attitudes of the required kind. This problem is distinct from, and broader than, well-known problems about whether political toleration is normatively legitimate. To make sense of political toleration or respect, the paper proposes that the analysis of institutional toleration and respect should not be solely agent-centred (as in attitudinal analyses) or patient-centred (as in explanations of the good of toleration or respect in terms of the effects of being tolerated or respected). The analysis should also include features about the relation itself. We can describe institutions as tolerant or respectful in a sense relevantly similar to the standard analyses if we focus on the public features of the relation between institutions and citizens or groups, without ascribing attitudes in the problematic sense.

AB - Toleration and respect are types of relations between different agents. The standard analyses of toleration and respect are attitudinal; toleration and respect require subjects to have appropriate types of attitudes towards the objects of toleration or respect. The paper investigates whether states can sensibly be described as tolerant or respectful in ways theoretically relevantly similar to the standard analyses. This is a descriptive question about the applicability of concepts rather than a normative question about whether, when and why states should be tolerant or respectful. The problem of institutional application is that institutions in general and the state in particular arguably cannot have attitudes of the required kind. This problem is distinct from, and broader than, well-known problems about whether political toleration is normatively legitimate. To make sense of political toleration or respect, the paper proposes that the analysis of institutional toleration and respect should not be solely agent-centred (as in attitudinal analyses) or patient-centred (as in explanations of the good of toleration or respect in terms of the effects of being tolerated or respected). The analysis should also include features about the relation itself. We can describe institutions as tolerant or respectful in a sense relevantly similar to the standard analyses if we focus on the public features of the relation between institutions and citizens or groups, without ascribing attitudes in the problematic sense.

KW - toleration

KW - respect

KW - state

KW - institution

KW - attitudes

U2 - 10.1111/ejop.12027

DO - 10.1111/ejop.12027

M3 - Journal article

VL - 23

SP - 1064

EP - 1081

JO - European Journal of Philosophy

JF - European Journal of Philosophy

SN - 0966-8373

IS - 4

ER -